Jeff, I should know. All my friends are American and I've got them on Hindi movies. 'Fiza' is certainly the critical success it comes across as - most people cant believe the way it ends. If you liked 'Fiza' you should also see 'Zubeidaa' with Karisma Kapoor - its an artsy Indian film, and those are the kinds that kick Hollywood's sorry ass anyday!! Luckily 'Zubeidaa' is easily available in the US - the music is astonishingly good. The story is VERY different.
Theres a director called Mani Rathnam whose work I think best embodies the marvel of Indian moviemaking. Heres a list of his movies - if youre looking for the cream of Indian cinema, this would be your list - MOST are available in the US to buy:
1. Roja
2. Bombay
3. Dil Se
4. Iruvar
5. Alaipayuthey
6. Kannathil Muthamittaal
7. Thiruda Thiruda
You HAVE to see the above. Absolutely, totally. They are my favorites. 'Kandukondain' (
http://www.geocities.com/kandukondainthefilm) stars Aishwarya too and is superb. The DVD for this is excellent too.